Materials for Sanitary Heat Exchangers

The metal in the tubes, the rubber in the joints, and the paper trail.

Contact us

Three material decisions on every sanitary order

The product-contact metal, the elastomers, and the documentation are decided separately and they are each worth a page. The metal question is nearly always 304L or 316L, with a higher alloy only where chlorides or an aggressive cleaning chemistry demand it. The elastomer question is which compound survives the CIP chemistry and the SIP temperature while staying compliant for food or pharmaceutical contact. The documentation question is what the plant's QA program needs to see, from a simple material test report to a full turnover package.

Sanitary duty is easier on the metal than most chemical service and harder on the gaskets. Milk, juice, wort and purified water are mild. The cleaning cycle is not: hot caustic, acid, sometimes chlorine, and steam, several hundred times a year. Materials are chosen for the cleaning program first and the product second.

The three pages below give the grades, the compounds and the certificates. This page gives the reasoning.

304L & 316L

  • 304L: milk, juice, wort, sugar, plant water; the food default
  • 316L: brine, tomato, chlorinated sanitizer, pharma water; 2 to 3 percent molybdenum
  • Sulfur-controlled 316L for orbital welding on BPE work
  • Sanitary tube to ASTM A270; pressure tube to A269 or A249

Higher alloys

  • 2205 duplex for high chlorides and stress corrosion resistance
  • AL-6XN (6 percent Mo) for hot chloride and seawater-grade duty
  • Hastelloy C-22 for aggressive CIP, hot acids, mixed oxidizers
  • Titanium for chlorinated seawater or hot brine cooling

Gaskets & Elastomers

  • EPDM for water, caustic and most CIP; the sanitary default
  • FKM (fluoroelastomer) for fats, oils and flavor solvents that swell EPDM
  • Silicone for the highest dry-heat temperatures; softer, shorter life in steam
  • PTFE and PTFE-enveloped where chemistry defeats the elastomers

Certs & Traceability

  • MTRs to EN 10204 3.1 for every wetted heat
  • Heat numbers on the weld map, so any joint traces to its mill cert
  • Surface finish, passivation and hydrotest reports as deliverables
  • Turnover package assembled for pharma validation
1

Check for chlorides

brine, tomato, citrus, hypochlorite sanitizer at any step

2

Pick the grade

304L by default, 316L once chlorides appear

3

Match the elastomer

EPDM for CIP, FKM for fats and oils

4

Ask for paper

MTR per wetted heat, compound compliance per gasket

Choosing the stainless grade

304L is the correct choice for most food and dairy product contact. It resists the product, the caustic and the nitric or phosphoric acid without difficulty and costs less than 316L. What it does not resist is chloride: hot brine, tomato and citrus concentrates, pickle liquor, and any sanitizer built on hypochlorite. Chloride pitting starts at crevices and welds, and once a pit is through a tube wall the unit is scrap. If chlorides are present at any step, product or cleaning, 316L is the floor, and its pitting resistance equivalent number (PREN) of about 24 against 304L's 19 is the reason.

Pharmaceutical water is a different case. WFI at 80 C is not corrosive in the usual sense but it rouges 304L quickly, and BPE work is 316L by convention and by nearly every specification.

When to go higher

Above 316L the choice is driven by chloride level and temperature together. 2205 duplex, with a PREN around 35, handles hot brines and gives roughly twice the yield strength, which means thinner walls. AL-6XN at PREN 45 or more handles seawater and hot concentrated brines. Hastelloy C-22 is for aggressive cleaning chemistry that combines acids and oxidizers, rarely needed on food but seen in some biotech kill systems. Each step up roughly doubles the material cost of the wetted parts, and none of them is needed for milk.

Elastomers are the wear item

The gasket compound is chosen for the cleaning program, then checked against the product. EPDM handles hot water, caustic, and nitric or phosphoric acid and is the default in dairy, beverage and pharma water. It swells in fats and oils, which is why FKM takes over on edible oil, cream at high fat, and flavor solvents. Silicone tolerates the highest dry-heat temperatures but ages faster than EPDM in saturated steam, and is soft and abrades in clamp joints. All of them are supplied in compounds compliant with FDA 21 CFR 177, and USP Class VI compounds are used where the pharmaceutical specification asks for it.

Ask for the paper

Every wetted heat of metal should arrive with a mill test report and every product-contact gasket with its compound compliance statement. On pharmaceutical work the fabricator ties them together on a weld map so an auditor can pick any joint and trace it to its certificates.
Call and talk it through with an engineer: 1-805-484-2992

Material Questions

Welded A270 tube is accepted by 3-A and BPE and is what most sanitary bundles use. The seam is cold worked and polished with the bore, so a profilometer trace across it reads the same Ra as the parent metal. Seamless tube costs more and is specified for higher pressures or where a pharmaceutical standard names it; it does not clean any better. Either form is fine if the order says which: write the tube standard, the grade, welded or seamless, and the Ra, and the mill certificate will show all four.

In a washdown room, yes. The exterior takes the same caustic, acid and sanitizer as the floor, and a painted carbon steel shell eventually drops paint and rust flakes near open product. 3-A asks for non-product surfaces that are corrosion resistant or durably coated, and a dairy inspector reads a rusting saddle as a finding. A carbon steel shell is defensible only in a utility room well away from exposed product, so tell us which room the unit is for and the shell is quoted to suit.

Yes, and it is the side buyers forget. The outside of every tube sees the utility, so cooling tower water with several hundred ppm chlorides, a chlorinated chilled loop or a calcium chloride brine can pit or stress-crack 304L tubes from the shell side while the product bore stays perfect. The product contamination at the end is the same as a product-side failure. Send a water analysis or the coolant chemistry with the inquiry; a tower that is cycled up to save water concentrates its chlorides, so send the blowdown analysis, not the makeup figure. If the tower water runs high, 316L tubes in a 304L shell is a common and sensible split, and the quote will show both grades.

For the stainless, rarely; for the carbon steel it touches, yes. Stainless is the more noble metal, so a stainless shell on painted carbon steel saddles or a mild steel skid frame in a wet room makes the steel corrode faster at the contact, and rust runs down the shell where an auditor sees it. Use stainless saddles and frames in washdown areas, or isolate the contact with a nonconductive pad.

By keeping carbon steel tools, abrasives and handling gear away from the stainless entirely. A grinding wheel, wire brush or roller used on carbon steel embeds iron particles in a stainless surface; those rust within days in a humid shop, sometimes before the unit is even crated and shipped, and each spot can seed a pit. A sanitary shop runs stainless-only abrasives and work areas and lifts with nylon slings rather than chain. Passivation then dissolves any free iron that got through, and the passivation certificate, with its ferroxyl or copper sulfate test result, is your evidence that it did. Ask for that certificate on every sanitary order, not only pharmaceutical ones.

Between 304L and 316L, no; above them, yes. The two grades have the same conductivity and wall, so the thermal design carries over unchanged. Duplex 2205 allows a thinner wall for the same pressure, which changes both heat transfer and tube count. Hastelloy C-22 conducts heat at roughly 60 percent of the rate of 316L, so a tube wall that was a few percent of the total resistance in stainless matters more and the surface grows. A late alloy switch means rerunning the thermal and mechanical design; settle the alloy before drawings start, ideally at the inquiry stage.

Related

Sanitary Standards for Heat Exchangers

Design & Fabrication

Sanitary Standards

3-A, ASME BPE and food-grade drainable: what each one requires, what it costs, and how to pick the right one.

+ Learn More
Product-Contact Design for Sanitary Heat Exchangers

Design & Fabrication

Product-Contact Design

The four details that decide whether the product side cleans, drains and stays uncontaminated.

+ Learn More
Codes and Certification for Sanitary Heat Exchangers

Design & Fabrication

Codes & Certification

Pressure codes, registration numbers and sanitary marks: what each is, who requires it, and where it goes.

+ Learn More

Quote Request Form:

Questions?

1-805-484-2992

Quotes - Engineering - Sales