Flow and temperatures fix the duty; the approach temperature and the decision on regeneration fix how much of that duty the utility has to supply and how much surface it takes to do it. Two plants running the same 10,000 lb/h of milk to the same 165 F can have utility bills that differ by a factor of ten, and the difference is entirely in whether the hot pasteurized product is used to preheat the cold raw product on its way in.
This page is about stating those inputs correctly and about deciding regeneration before anything is sized, because a regenerative unit is a different machine from a straight heater, not a bigger one.
Where the cooler starts with regenerationOnce the outgoing milk preheats the incoming raw milk, chilled water picks up the product at 53°F instead of 165°F, and the cooler shrinks to a tenth of its size.
Raw milk at 40 F is heated to 165 F, held, and cooled to 38 F for storage. Without regeneration the heater supplies the full 125 F rise, about 1.16 MMBtu/h at 10,000 lb/h, and the cooler removes 127 F of it again with chilled water, another 1.18 MMBtu/h. With a regeneration section the hot milk leaving the holding tube gives its heat to the cold milk coming in. At 90% regeneration the raw milk arrives at the heater already at 152 F, the heater adds 13 F, and the cooler starts at 53 F instead of 165 F.
The heater and the cooler shrink to a tenth of their size and the hot water and chilled water demand shrink with them. The regenerator itself is large, because it moves 1.05 MMBtu/h at about a 13 F approach, but it uses no utility at all.
Flow is misread more often than any other input. A line rated at 60 gpm is often started at 45 and pushed to 70 on a busy day, and the exchanger needs to hold outlet temperature across that whole range. State the maximum for sizing and the minimum for control, because a unit with a wide turndown needs a utility valve that can throttle far enough without hunting. On plates, low flow also means low channel velocity, which drops the coefficient and lets deposits settle; if the night shift runs at half rate, say so and the plate pattern can be chosen for it.
Temperatures are usually stated correctly but incompletely. The product inlet is the temperature at the exchanger, after the balance tank, not the silo set point. The outlet is the required temperature plus the tolerance: a pasteurizer that must never dip below 161 F and is set at 165 F has a 4 F margin, and the control loop and the surface area both have to respect it. On the utility side, supply temperature is one number and return temperature is another; if the plant's hot water set has a fixed return, the utility flow is fixed too, and that can cap the duty regardless of the exchanger.
Approach temperature is a cost decision dressed up as a thermal one. The closer the product outlet is allowed to come to the utility inlet, the less utility is wasted, and the more surface is bought to get there. On a gasketed plate a 2 to 3 F approach is routine and a 1 F approach is possible on clean fluids at some cost in plates. On a sanitary shell-and-tube the approach is 10 F or more, because the geometry is not fully counterflow and the coefficient is lower. A tube-in-tube in series is fully counterflow and can be pushed to a 5 F approach on viscous product, at a price in length.
A temperature cross, where the cold stream leaves warmer than the hot stream leaves, is only possible in true counterflow. It is what a regenerator does all day: raw milk leaves the regenerator at 152 F while pasteurized milk leaves it at 53 F. A shell-and-tube with two tube passes cannot do that in one shell, and asking it to is the commonest cause of an impossible sizing. If the duty needs a cross, it is plates, tube-in-tube, or shells in series.
Regeneration is decided by the utility bill and by the product. On HTST milk the answer is nearly always yes, at 85 to 95%. On a juice pasteurizer it is usually yes. On a small batch process that runs an hour a day the payback may not be there. On a viscous product the regenerator approach widens to 10 or 15 F and efficiency falls to 70 or 80%, which is still worth having. The design has to fix the efficiency first, because it sets the inlet temperature to the heater and the outlet from the cooler, and therefore the size of both.
The pressure balance across a regenerator is a hygiene requirement, not a thermal one. Pasteurized product must be at a higher pressure than raw product wherever they share a plate or a tube wall, so that any leak goes the safe way. That is arranged with a booster pump on the raw side after the regenerator, or a timing pump downstream, and the exchanger's pressure drops on each side have to be known to set it. It is one more reason to specify the pressure drop budget with the flow rather than accept whatever falls out.
Utility flow is the input most often left off the sheet. A 190 F hot water set that returns at 175 F delivers 15 F per pound of water, so a 1.16 MMBtu/h heater needs about 155 gpm of water; with regeneration at 90% it needs 16 gpm. A chilled water loop at 36 F with a 10 F rise on a 1.18 MMBtu/h cooler needs about 236 gpm; with regeneration, under 30 gpm. Give the utility flow the plant can actually spare and the size and the regeneration decision can be made together.
Call and talk it through with an engineer: 1-805-484-2992
By pricing each step in efficiency against the regenerator surface it costs, using the plant's own energy rate and run hours. With equal raw and pasteurized flows the two streams change temperature by the same amount, so the temperature difference across the regenerator is the same at both ends: at 90 percent on the 40 F to 165 F pasteurizer it is 12.5 F, at 95 percent it is 6.25 F. Moving from 90 to 95 percent therefore roughly doubles the regenerator area while the duty it recovers rises from 1.05 to about 1.10 MMBtu/h, a gain near 5 percent. A line running around the clock on expensive steam often justifies that; a single-shift line usually stops near 90. Fix the figure before the heater and cooler are sized, because both inherit their inlet temperatures from it.
Sometimes on a plate frame with spare length, rarely on a shell-and-tube, and in both cases the control loop changes more than the exchanger does. The figures on this page show why: the heater's duty drops from 1.16 to about 0.12 MMBtu/h and its hot water demand from 155 gpm to 16 gpm. A control valve and pump selected for 155 gpm are then asked to modulate at a tenth of their range, which is where valves hunt and the flow diversion valve starts tripping. The booster pump and the pressure differential between raw and pasteurized sides must be added at the same time. If growth into regeneration is likely, buy the frame with that section in mind.
Because the regenerator passes a fixed fraction of the temperature span, so every degree the raw milk arrives warmer moves straight through to the cooler. At 90 percent, raw milk at 40 F leaves the regenerator at 152 F and the cooler starts at 53 F. Raw milk at 50 F in summer leaves at 153.5 F, but the cooler now starts at 61.5 F and has to remove 23.5 F instead of 15 F, about 57 percent more chilled-water load. The heater sees the opposite in winter. Give the seasonal range of raw inlet temperature so each section is checked in its own worst month.
It fixes which side of the regenerator runs at the higher pressure, and that must be on the plate arrangement and the data sheet before the frame is laid out. The Pasteurized Milk Ordinance requires the pasteurized side to stay at least 1 psi above the raw side at all times, so the pressure drop on each side at maximum and minimum flow has to be quoted, since the booster or timing pump is set from those. Locate the differential pressure sensing points while the frame is on the drawing, not after it is piped.
Duty, log mean temperature difference and a realistic U-value, worked through on a milk heater.
+ Learn More
The two product properties that move a duty from plates to a wide gap to a tube.
+ Learn More
Duty, temperature difference and the U-value your product will actually give you.
+ Learn More