Once the duty is known, the construction is chosen by what the product will tolerate and what the hygiene class demands. Thin, clean liquids at close approach go to gasketed plates. Higher pressures, steam service and pharma water go to shell-and-tube. Viscous, fibrous or particulate product goes to tube-in-tube. Where product must never reach the utility side, a double tubesheet or a double-wall plate is added on top of whichever construction was chosen.
The three pages in this branch take those decisions one at a time, with the numbers that separate a comfortable selection from a marginal one.
Talk to an Application Specialist
thin and clean to plates, viscous or with pieces to tubes
past 500 cP or 150 psig, plates give way to tubes
double tubesheet or double-wall plate where a leak must show
hot water loop on heat-sensitive product, glycol below chilled water
A gasketed plate unit gives the highest coefficient per square foot and the closest approach, opens for inspection, and grows or shrinks by adding plates, which is why it dominates HTST, juice, beer and wort duty. A sanitary shell-and-tube carries higher pressure and temperature, tolerates steam on the shell side, and can be built with a double tubesheet, seal-welded tubes and full ASME documentation, which is why it dominates WFI, clean steam and CIP heating. A tube-in-tube passes whatever fits through the inner tube, sauce, fruit prep, yogurt with fruit, egg, and is drained and cleaned end to end without disassembly.
Viscosity above about 500 cP takes a product out of a standard plate pack; the pressure drop needed to keep the channels turbulent becomes more than a sanitary pump will give. Particles larger than an eighth of an inch or fibers that bridge a plate gap take it out of standard plates as well, though a wide-gap plate will handle pulp and small particulates. Pressures above roughly 150 psig, or any duty with steam on the utility side, favor shell-and-tube. A required 2 to 3 F approach favors plates or a long counterflow tube-in-tube; shell-and-tube wants 10 F or more.
Shell-and-tube with a single tubesheet, and single-wall plates, keep product and utility apart by one joint or one plate. That is normal food-grade practice with a potable utility. Where the utility is boiler water with treatment chemicals, or the product is WFI, a parenteral, a cell culture medium or a product where one contaminated batch outweighs the cost of the exchanger, the second barrier is specified: a double tubesheet with a vented gap, or double-wall plates with a vented interspace. Either one makes a leak visible before it becomes a mixing event.
The utility decides wall temperature, and wall temperature decides whether a dairy product burns on, a juice loses flavor, or a protein denatures on the surface. Plant steam at 150 psig on a milk heater is a burn-on machine unless it is throttled hard; a 190 F hot water loop is gentle and controllable. On the cold side, chilled water at 34 to 40 F will cool milk to 38 F but will not cool wort to 50 F fast enough on a hot day, so brewers run propylene glycol at 20 to 30 F. Extraction cold traps run at minus 40 F and need a construction rated for it.
Call and talk it through with an engineer: 1-805-484-2992
The hygiene class, because it removes constructions before any thermal number is run. A duty validated to ASME BPE goes straight to a double-barrier build, in practice a double tubesheet shell-and-tube or double-wall plates, whatever the coefficient says, while a 3-A dairy duty leaves plates, shell-and-tube and tube-in-tube all in play. Choosing on coefficient first is how a gasketed plate gets quoted for a WFI point-of-use cooler and then rejected by the validation team, after which the sizing starts over as a tubular with double tubesheets and a 10 F approach instead of 3 F. Put the class and the audit standard on the first line of the sheet.
Yes, if it is chosen for the thickest product and then checked on the thinnest, never the other way around. A tube-in-tube sized for a 2,000 cP sauce will carry a thin product at low pressure drop, though at a wider approach than a plate would give. A plate pack chosen for the thin product has nowhere to go when the sauce arrives above 500 cP; the pump head is simply not there. Where both run long, two units on one utility often cost less.
Enough to be stated as a number on the sheet, because the constructions grow very differently. A plate frame bought with spare length takes a flow increase for the price of the plates; a shell-and-tube bundle is fixed and the usual fix is a second shell in series or parallel. If the line is expected to grow, say by how much and when, and the frame or shell is picked so the first increase is not a new unit.
It changes what has to be shown, not whether cleaning has to be proven. A plate unit opens and is swabbed, so the cleaning program is confirmed by eye and by ATP swab. A shell-and-tube or tube-in-tube is verified from flow, temperature and chemical records, a final rinse check and a borescope at intervals, because nobody sees the tube wall. QA teams used to opening equipment should accept that before a tubular is selected for a 3-A line, since the records and the inspection schedule take the place of the visual check at audit.
Both, and it is often the cheapest answer to a selection that looks hard. A closed potable water loop between treated plant steam and the product exchanger does three things at once: it removes the case for a double tubesheet on a food duty, because the utility touching the product barrier is now potable; it drops the wall temperature from near 366 F steam to a 190 F loop, so milk, egg and juice stop burning on; and it lets a gasketed plate run where raw steam at plant pressure would rule it out on gasket temperature. The price is a steam-to-water exchanger, a pump, an expansion tank and one more control loop. On a dairy pasteurizer that trade is made without hesitation; on a CIP heater, where the fluid is caustic and does not care about wall temperature, direct steam into a shell-and-tube is simpler. Tell us whether the utility is fixed or can still be designed around the exchanger.
One duty, three constructions, and the six questions that pick between them.
+ Learn More
Where a tube-to-tubesheet leak would go, what it would cost, and whether the second sheet is required.
+ Learn More
The utility sets the wall temperature, and the wall temperature decides whether the product survives the pass.
+ Learn More