Product-Contact Design for Sanitary Heat Exchangers

Four details that decide whether the product side cleans and drains.

Contact us

The product side is a different design problem

On an industrial exchanger both sides are designed for heat transfer and pressure drop and nothing else. On a sanitary exchanger one side carries the product, and that side has to satisfy a second set of rules: it must be smooth enough that soil releases under CIP, shaped so that nothing stays behind when the pump stops, sealed so the utility can never reach it, and able to take the chemical and thermal punishment of a cleaning cycle several hundred times a year without changing.

Those four requirements map to four design details. Surface finish and electropolish set how fast the surface cleans and how long it resists corrosion. The tubesheet arrangement sets how the product is protected from the utility. Connections and orientation set whether the unit drains. And the CIP and SIP program the unit will face sets the gasket material, the tube wall, and how the design handles thermal cycling.

Each detail has a page below with the numbers. This page explains how they interact, because a decision on one changes the others.

Surface Finish

  • 32 Ra product side is the food default; 15 to 20 Ra for pharma
  • Mechanical polish to 180, 240 or 320 grit, then electropolish where specified
  • Electropolish removes 0.0002 to 0.0005 inch and passivates in one step
  • Utility side commonly left at 63 Ra or mill finish to save cost

Double Tubesheet

  • Two tubesheets with an air gap between them at each end
  • A failed joint leaks to atmosphere, not into the other fluid
  • Standard on WFI and most pharma; optional on food with potable utility
  • Adds length, tube count and price; removable-bundle versions exist

Connections & Drainability

  • Tri-clamp 1.5 to 4 inch is the North American default
  • I-line, bevel seat, DIN 11851 and SMS where the plant already uses them
  • Low-point drain and high-point vent on the product side, always
  • Orientation and slope shown on the drawing, not left to the installer

CIP & SIP

  • Caustic at 160 to 180 F, then acid, at 5 ft/s through the product channel
  • SIP at 250 F for 30 minutes cycles the whole unit hot and cold
  • Gasket compound chosen for the chemistry, not just the temperature
  • Plate units open for inspection; shell-and-tube units rely on velocity
1

Pick the side

product on the tube side, away from baffles

2

Settle the drain

low nozzle, high vent, slope on the drawing

3

Choose tubesheets

single for potable utility, double for pharma

4

Set the finish

32 Ra for food, 15 to 20 Ra pharma

How the four details interact

A double tubesheet on a straight-tube unit means four tubesheet faces to polish instead of two, which is where the finish cost climbs on a pharma order. Electropolish makes the CIP faster but does nothing for a horizontal unit that holds product in the head; the drain comes first. Putting product on the tube side to keep it out of the baffled shell makes a single tubesheet acceptable on food duty, but it also fixes the tube velocity, which has to be high enough for CIP even if the process flow is low.

The right order of decisions is: which side is product, how the unit drains, what tubesheet arrangement the duty needs, and only then the finish grade.

The design most food plants should buy

Product on the tube side, single tubesheet with seal-welded and polished tube joints, 32 Ra product side, 63 Ra utility side, tri-clamp product connections, a low-point drain and a high-point vent, mounted on a slope, EPDM gaskets. That unit cleans in place, drains dry, passes a customer audit and is priced sensibly. Everything past it is for a specific reason: 316L for chlorides, a double tubesheet for a non-potable utility or a pharmaceutical product, electropolish for hot WFI or a QA group that wants it.

Where the utility side matters

The utility side is usually treated as industrial, and that is correct as long as the utility is steam, plant hot water, chilled water or glycol. Two cases change it. If the utility is a second product stream, as in a regenerative section of a pasteurizer, both sides are product-contact and both get the sanitary treatment. If the unit will be stored idle and cold, the utility side should drain too, or the water left in it will corrode the tubes from the outside in over a winter.

Getting the drawing right

The general arrangement should show which nozzle is product in and out, the slope, the drain and vent, the gasket material at every joint, the finish on each surface, and the tubesheet arrangement in section. A drawing with those items on it can be approved by QA without a meeting.
Call and talk it through with an engineer: 1-805-484-2992

Design and Acceptance Questions

At transitions, not in the tubes. The corner where a head meets the tubesheet, the weld where a nozzle joins the head and the step where a ferrule bore meets the head bore are where grinding and polishing are hardest and where a ledge or undercut is left. At the factory acceptance test, put a borescope and a strong light on those spots.

With a drain test at the installed slope. Set the unit on blocks at the drawing slope, which at 1/8 inch per foot means the far end of a 10 foot shell sits 1.25 inch higher than the drain end, fill the product side, open the drain, and borescope the heads and the low tubes for standing water. A unit that fails usually fails at the head floor below the nozzle centerline, not in the tubes. Half an hour in the shop beats finding a puddle at installation qualification with the unit already piped in.

Both sides become product-contact, and the pressure relationship becomes a design requirement, not an operating habit. Under the PMO a milk-to-milk regenerator must hold the pasteurized side at least 1 psi above the raw side, so any leak sends pasteurized milk toward raw, never the reverse. That rule fixes pump placement, the booster pump interlock, the pressure recorder and which stream gets which side of the plate pack or bundle. Mark which stream is raw and which is pasteurized on the drawing, and state the differential.

Yes. Fabrication leaves embedded iron from tooling and chromium-depleted heat tint at welds, and a plant CIP acid step at 0.5 to 1.5 percent for 15 minutes is not a controlled passivation. The shop treatment runs a written procedure at a specified concentration, time and temperature, is verified by a copper sulfate or ferroxyl test, and produces a certificate the auditor can read. Routine nitric washes then maintain the passive film rather than having to create it.

Related

Sanitary Standards for Heat Exchangers

Design & Fabrication

Sanitary Standards

3-A, ASME BPE and food-grade drainable: what each one requires, what it costs, and how to pick the right one.

+ Learn More
Materials for Sanitary Heat Exchangers

Design & Fabrication

Materials

The metal in the tubes, the rubber in the joints, and the paper that proves which heat went where.

+ Learn More
Codes and Certification for Sanitary Heat Exchangers

Design & Fabrication

Codes & Certification

Pressure codes, registration numbers and sanitary marks: what each is, who requires it, and where it goes.

+ Learn More

Quote Request Form:

Questions?

1-805-484-2992

Quotes - Engineering - Sales