304L and 316L are both austenitic stainless steels with about 18 percent chromium. 316L adds 2 to 3 percent molybdenum and a little more nickel, and that molybdenum is the whole difference in service: it raises resistance to pitting and crevice corrosion in the presence of chlorides. Everything else, from polishability to weldability to strength, is close enough that the two are interchangeable in fabrication.
So the choice comes down to one question: will the product-contact surface see chlorides, hot, at any point in the product or the cleaning cycle? If not, 304L. If so, 316L. If the chlorides are high and hot, brine chillers and some concentrates, neither is enough and the duplex and superaustenitic grades take over. Pharmaceutical water is 316L by specification regardless. Below: how to pick between the two grades, what PREN tells you, and the alloys above them for chlorides.
Milk and cream, whey, juice without added salt, wort and beer, wine, sugar syrup, edible oil, plant hot water, chilled water and steam are all mild to 304L. A standard CIP program of caustic followed by nitric or phosphoric acid does not attack it. It is the correct default for food and dairy shell-and-tube and tube-in-tube exchangers, and it is what most 3-A units are made from.
The one caveat is the sanitizer. A plant that finishes its CIP with a hypochlorite rinse is putting chloride on the hot surface every day. On 304L that produces pitting at the tube welds within a few years. Peracetic acid sanitizers avoid the problem; if hypochlorite is the plant standard, buy 316L.
Chlorides in the product make the decision: brine and pickle liquors, tomato and citrus concentrates, sauces with added salt, sports drinks with electrolytes, and any seawater-derived ingredient. So does hot purified water: WFI at 80 C and hot purified water loops rouge 304L quickly and every BPE specification calls for 316L. For orbital welding on BPE work the tube and fittings should be sulfur-controlled 316L, with sulfur held between about 0.005 and 0.017 percent, because sulfur at the low end of the ordinary range gives shallow, wandering weld penetration and mismatched sulfur between two parts steers the weld pool toward one side.
PREN, the pitting resistance equivalent number, is the shorthand: chromium plus 3.3 times molybdenum plus 16 times nitrogen. 304L at about 19 and 316L at about 24 sit close together; the practical rule is that 316L tolerates roughly twice the chloride at the same temperature before pitting begins.
When chlorides are high, brine chillers below 30 F running 20 percent sodium chloride, seawater cooling, hot concentrated pickle liquor, the PREN of 316L is not enough, and on the hot duties stress corrosion cracking joins pitting as a failure mode. 2205 duplex at PREN 35 resists both, and its higher yield strength allows a thinner tube wall for the same pressure, which partly offsets its cost. AL-6XN, a superaustenitic grade with 6 percent molybdenum, handles seawater and the hottest brines and polishes and welds much like 316L. Hastelloy C-22 is a nickel-base alloy reserved for cleaning or process chemistry that mixes acids and oxidizers, as in some biotech decontamination systems; it is not a food alloy in any normal sense.
Each of these alloys is ordered for a named chemistry, never as a general upgrade.
A sanitary exchanger tube is bought to ASTM A270, the sanitary tubing standard, which calls for polished surfaces and controlled dimensions, in 304L or 316L, welded or seamless. The bundle's utility-side tube on a double-tubesheet or an industrial-utility unit may be to A269 or A249, the general and heat-exchanger tube standards, where a polished bore is not needed. The mill certificate for each heat states the standard, the grade, the chemistry and the mechanical properties, and it is the document that proves the tube is what the drawing says.
State the product-contact grade, the shell-side grade if different, the tube standard, and whether seamless or welded tube is required. Add the chloride source if there is one, so the choice can be confirmed against the actual chemistry.
Call and talk it through with an engineer: 1-805-484-2992
Yes. Dual-certified 316/316L meets the 0.030 percent carbon limit of the L grade and the strength minimums of straight 316 at the same time, and it is what most mills ship. It satisfies a 316L specification fully and lets the pressure design use the higher allowable stress, since 316 has a 30 ksi minimum yield against 25 ksi for 316L. Check that the mill certificate names both grades; a certificate that says 316 alone does not prove low carbon, and low carbon is what keeps the weld heat-affected zone from sensitizing.
Because chlorides were concentrated somewhere the grade selection never considered. The common sites: water left standing after CIP that evaporates and concentrates chlorides on a horizontal head floor; deposits that create crevices; unpurged weld roots carrying chromium-depleted heat tint; and embedded iron from fabrication. Dry draining, purged welds and shop passivation remove most of them. If a 316L surface that is drained, clean and well made still pits, the chemistry is beyond the grade and the answer is duplex or AL-6XN, not a thicker 316L wall.
Above about 140 F, with chlorides and tensile stress present together; below that, pitting is the likelier failure in 304L and 316L. That is why a 20 percent sodium chloride brine at 25 F is a pitting question while the same brine at 180 F is a cracking question. Molybdenum improves pitting resistance but does little for stress cracking, so hot chloride duty goes to 2205 duplex rather than to a heavier 316L wall. Residual stress from tube expansion and welding counts as tensile stress, so a tube joint carrying no external load can still crack. Tell us the hottest wall temperature the chloride stream reaches, not the bulk temperature; the tube wall on the steam side of a brine heater runs well above the brine.
No. Both grades are essentially nonmagnetic when annealed, and cold work or weld metal can make either one slightly magnetic. A magnet cannot separate 304L from 316L and cannot catch a cheaper nonmagnetic grade such as 200-series stainless. Shops still try it at receiving; it rejects a 400-series part and passes every austenitic one. Proof is the heat's mill certificate and, where the specification asks, a handheld XRF alloy analyzer that reads the 2 to 3 percent molybdenum 316L carries and 304L lacks.
Rarely. On a fabricated sanitary exchanger the product-contact metal is a modest share of the price, so the 316L premium on the finished unit is small. Polishing, welding, documentation and testing cost the same in either grade. Against that, a bundle lost to pitting a few years in costs the unit plus the downtime and a lost batch. Whenever a salted product, a hypochlorite step or uncertain water chemistry is in the picture, buy 316L. Where chlorides are truly absent, 304L is correct and the saving is real; the mistake is to call it borderline when nobody has checked the sanitizer.
Which compound survives your CIP, your product and your steam, and how long before it needs changing.
+ Learn More
The documents that prove what was welded in, how it was finished and that it held pressure.
+ Learn More
The metal in the tubes, the rubber in the joints, and the paper that proves which heat went where.
+ Learn More