CIP and SIP Design

What cleaning and sterilizing cycles do to metal, gaskets and joints.

Contact us

The exchanger is designed for the CIP, not just the product

A sanitary heat exchanger spends a few hours a day on product and, over its life, a few thousand hours on cleaning solution. Clean-in-place runs hot caustic, then acid, then sanitizer through the product side at a velocity higher than the process flow. Sterilize-in-place pushes clean steam through the same side at 250 F and holds it. Every one of those cycles heats the unit, swells and relaxes the gaskets, and works the tube-to-tubesheet joints through a temperature swing. The unit that lasts is the one designed with that in mind.

The design questions are specific: what velocity the CIP needs and what pressure drop that creates, which gasket compound survives both the caustic and the acid, how much thermal expansion the bundle sees between a 40 F product and a 250 F sterilization, and whether the construction can be inspected after cleaning or has to be trusted.

CIP

  • Caustic at 160 to 180 F, then acid
  • Pressure drop rises fourfold at 5 ft/s
  • Rate heads and gaskets for CIP pump head
VS

SIP

  • Clean steam at 250 F held 30 minutes
  • Expansion 0.1 inch per 10 feet per 100 F
  • U-tube bundle or shell expansion joint

Typical CIP and SIP conditions

CIP cycle

  • Pre-rinse: Warm water, 100 to 120 F, until return runs clear
  • Caustic wash: 1 to 2 percent sodium hydroxide at 160 to 180 F, 20 to 40 minutes
  • Acid wash: Nitric or phosphoric, 0.5 to 1.5 percent, 130 to 160 F, 10 to 20 minutes
  • Velocity: About 5 ft/s in tubes; 1.5 to 2 times process flow on plates
  • Sanitize: Hot water 185 F or chemical sanitizer, then final rinse

SIP and cycling

  • SIP: Clean steam at 250 F (about 15 psig) held 30 minutes
  • Temperature swing: 40 F product to 250 F steam, several times a week
  • Gasket life: EPDM typically 1 to 2 years on daily CIP; less with frequent SIP
  • Bundle expansion: Roughly 0.1 inch per 10 feet per 100 F on 316L
  • Design pressure: Rated for SIP steam pressure plus any CIP pump head

Design for the hottest, fastest, harshest hour

Building for cleaning and sterilizing

Velocity and pressure drop

CIP works by chemistry and by shear. The chemistry is handled by the skid; the shear is handled by the exchanger geometry and the CIP pump. In sanitary tube a velocity of about 5 ft/s is the common target for turbulent flow that lifts soil from a 32 Ra surface, and on a unit whose process flow gives only 2 ft/s the CIP flow has to be more than double the process flow. That raises the tube-side pressure drop by a factor of four or more, and the tube-side design pressure and the head gaskets have to be rated for it. On plate exchangers the equivalent rule is 1.5 to 2 times process flow, and the port velocity, not the channel velocity, is what limits it.

  • Give both process and CIP flow rates on the specification
  • Multi-pass tube arrangements raise velocity at the cost of pressure drop; three or four passes are common on small units
  • Product on the shell side is hard to clean at velocity; keep it in the tubes

Caustic, acid and the metal

One to two percent caustic at 180 F does nothing to 304L or 316L; it is the reason the exchanger is stainless. The acid step is where care is needed. Nitric acid is passivating and is the safer choice for the metal. Phosphoric acid is common and acceptable. Chlorinated sanitizers and any acid step with chlorides in the water are where 304L begins to pit, and a plant that uses them should be on 316L for the product side.


The cleaning cycle, not the product, sets the design pressure and gaskets.

  • Caustic 1 to 2 percent at 160 to 180°F
  • Clean steam at 250°F held 30 minutes
  • Tube velocity about 5 ft/s, plates 1.5 to 2 times flow

SIP and thermal cycling

Sterilize-in-place at 250 F for 30 minutes is a modest condition for the metal and a hard one for the assembly. Between a cold product run and a steam hold the bundle grows about 0.1 inch per 10 feet per 100 F, and on a fixed-tubesheet straight-tube unit the shell and tubes fight over that diffrence at every cycle. Three answers exist: a U-tube bundle that expands freely, an expansion joint in the shell, or a shell-and-tube design short enough that the stress stays within the ASME allowable. The fabricator's thermal design should show which one was used and the number of cycles it was checked against.

Gaskets see the same cycle. Each SIP compresses and heat-ages the elastomer; EPDM that lasts two years on CIP alone may need replacing yearly with weekly SIP, and silicone or a steam-grade EPDM is chosen for joints that are steamed often.


Cleanability by construction type

A gasketed plate exchanger is the easiest to verify clean: open the frame, look at every plate, swab if the program calls for it. It is also the one with the most gaskets and the tightest channels, so particulates and burn-on can bridge a channel and the CIP flow goes around it. A shell-and-tube unit with product in polished tubes cleans reliably at velocity and can be borescoped through the heads, but cannot be opened for a full visual without pulling the bundle. A tube-in-tube unit has one product channel with no bypass path and is the best choice for viscous or fouling product, at the cost of surface per dollar.


Writing CIP and SIP into the specification

Give the CIP chemistry and temperatures, the CIP flow rate, the SIP temperture and frequency, and the sanitizer. Those five items fix the material, the gaskets, the design pressure, the pass arrangement and the expansion provision.
Call and talk it through with an engineer: 1-805-484-2992 The case for automating the cleaning cycle in the first place is set out on our advantages of clean-in-place page.

Cleaning Cycle Questions

Yes, and it saves a separate CIP heater on many lines. The steam or hot water side brings the circulating caustic up to 160 to 180 F as it passes. Two cautions. The control loop needs a CIP setpoint, or the utility valve runs wide open on a cold caustic charge and the outlet overshoots; on a cooler, the chilled water or glycol side must be isolated and ideally drained so it is not fighting the wash and chilling the caustic back below strength. Give both the process and CIP heat loads, and the CIP flow, on the inquiry so the utility side and its control valve are sized for the larger.

By removing air and condensate. Air trapped in the product side insulates whatever it covers, and condensate pooled at a low point gives up heat to the metal and falls below the 250 F of the steam above it. So steam enters at the top, air leaves through a vent at the high point, and condensate leaves through a trap at the lowest drain. Put the temperature element for the hold at that drain, the coldest point; a sensor at the steam inlet reads 250 F while a far head may still be lagging. A unit with the slope cut into its saddles drains condensate to the outlet head on its own; a level unit holds a pool across the bottom row of tubes.

It works the unit harder than it needs to. On a fixed-tubesheet straight-tube unit the thin tubes cool faster than the shell, so a drop from 180 F caustic to 50 F rinse loads the tube joints at every cycle, and the gaskets shrink against a still-hot ferrule. A warm intermediate rinse costs little time and extends joint and gasket life, most of all on units cleaned every day. U-tube bundles tolerate the shock far better, which is one reason to choose them for daily CIP duty.

On plate exchangers and tube-in-tube units handling fibers or particulates, often yes; on a shell-and-tube with product in straight tubes, little. Particles wedge at the plate contact points or at a channel inlet in the process direction, and reverse flow lifts them out. If reverse flow is wanted, the CIP piping and valve matrix have to be laid out for it from the start, and the drain and vent still have to be at the low and high points in both directions.

Yes, a maintenance program rather than a sanitary one. Hot water and cooling water sides scale and foul like any industrial exchanger, and the lost heat transfer shows up as a CIP or a pasteurizer that cannot hold temperature at the old steam valve position. Descale on a schedule set by water quality, with a separate circulation loop and an acid compatible with the tube grade, and never route utility-side chemicals through the product-side CIP return, where a valve left open would put descaling acid in the product line. On a gasketed plate unit, opening the frame gives access to both sides at once, so the utility side can be cleaned by hand at the same shutdown.

By pairing evidence that the cycle ran with evidence of the result. Return temperature, conductivity and flow records show the solution reached the exchanger at strength and at velocity for the full time; on a bundle of 1 inch OD, 0.065 wall tube, 5 ft/s is about 9 gpm per tube, so the flow record can be checked against the tube count and pass arrangement. ATP or protein swabs at demountable joints, a borescope look into the heads and, on plate units, an inspection of opened plates show the outcome. Validation repeats both over several runs on worst-case soil.

Related

Surface Finish and Electropolish

Design & Fabrication

Surface Finish & Electropolish

Grit numbers, Ra values, what electropolish removes, and how to specify a finish the shop can prove.

+ Learn More
Double Tubesheet Design

Design & Fabrication

Double Tubesheet

Two tubesheets, an air gap, and a leak that shows up on the floor instead of in the product.

+ Learn More
Sanitary Connections and Drainability

Design & Fabrication

Connections & Drainability

Which fitting standard to use, what size, where the drain and vent go, and how the unit has to sit to empty.

+ Learn More

Quote Request Form:

Questions?

1-805-484-2992

Quotes - Engineering - Sales