Holding Tubes and Flow Diversion

Tube length from velocity and hold time, and the diversion valve.

Contact us

The legal hold

Where the 15 seconds actually happen

The heat exchanger gets the milk to 161 F. The holding tube keeps it there for 15 seconds, and the flow diversion valve at the end of the tube decides whether the milk goes forward to the cooler or back to the balance tank. Those two pieces, plus the recorder that watches them, are what an inspector times, seals and signs off.

Getting the tube right is arithmetic plus a few physical rules. Getting the valve right is buying the correct valve and wiring it to the correct signal. A pasteurizer sized perfectly and fitted with a tube 8 feet short is not a pasteurizer.

Sizing the tube, choosing the valve, wiring the recorder

Tube length from velocity and hold time

Length equals fastest-particle velocity times hold time. For 100 gpm in a 2.5 inch sanitary tube the mean velocity is about 7.3 ft/s; turbulent flow puts the fastest particle at 1.2 times mean, so 8.7 ft/s times 15 seconds is 131 feet of tube. Laminar flow, which cream and mix can reach, puts it at 2.0 times mean and doubles the length. The PMO does not let you assume turbulence: the tube is timed with a salt injection at the sealed pump setting and the measured hold governs.

The tube also has to hold temperature. Milk at 161 F loses heat to the room and the outlet sensor may read no more than 1 degree below the inlet, so long tubes in cold rooms get light insulation. It cannot be heated, because a heated tube is an exchanger.

  • Upward slope of 1/4 inch per foot so it drains and cannot trap air
  • No valves, reducers or instruments that change the cross-section
  • Outlet sensor within 18 inches of the diversion valve

The flow diversion valve

The valve at the tube outlet is a three-way sanitary valve: forward to the regenerator and cooler, or divert to the balance tank, failing to divert on loss of air or power. It must be leak-protect, with two seats and a vented cavity between them in divert, so a worn seat cannot let sub-temperature milk creep forward. Single-seat valves are not accepted.

Response is under one second, and the signal comes from the safety thermal limit recorder, not a PLC in the middle. When the valve diverts, the forward line loses pressure and the booster pump interlock trips at the same instant so the regenerator pressure rule holds. HeatX includes the divert leg in the pressure drop calculation so the timing pump cannot run faster in divert and shorten the hold.

The safety thermal limit recorder

The STLR reads the sensor at the tube outlet, pens the temperature on a chart, and closes a contact above the cut-in setpoint. The valve goes forward only on that contact. The inspector tests it by lowering the hot water until the pen crosses the line and watching the valve move; charts are kept for months.

What is not optional is the sensor location: after the tube, before the valve, in the product stream, not in a deep well that lags. A well can read 161 F while the milk it measures has been at 158 F for five seconds.

15 sec
at 161 F for milk, fastest particle
25 sec
at 175 F for ice cream mix
3–6 ft/s
mean velocity; fastest particle 1.2 to 2.0 times
1/4 in/ft
upward slope of the sanitary holding tube

The common mistake

A hold that changes with the product. A plant sizes the tube for milk at 100 gpm and turbulent flow, then runs 40 percent cream through it. Run cream at the milk setting and the flow can go laminar: the fastest particle moves at twice the average velocity instead of about 1.2 times, and the tube that held milk 15 seconds holds the fastest cream particle about 9. HeatX times the tube at the lowest Reynolds number on the product list; where a plant runs both, a second sealed pump setting with its own timed hold is the honest answer.

Send the products, the flow, the tube size or the room you have for one, and whether the recorder is new or existing.
Call and talk it through with an engineer: 1-805-484-2992

Holding tube and flow diversion process conditions

The rows list the tube, valve and recorder build we size to, along with the velocity and hold assumptions behind the length. Check them against your product and flow, then send your figures with the quote request.

Condition Detail
Product Milk, cream, mix or juice leaving the heating section at setpoint
Flow range Fixed by the sealed timing pump; 20 to 400 gpm
Temperatures in / out 161 F minimum at inlet; at most 1 degree lost to the outlet sensor
Hold 15 seconds at 161 F for milk; 25 seconds at 175 F for mix; at the fastest particle
Utility None; the tube cannot be heated
Velocity 3 to 6 ft/s mean; fastest particle 1.2 to 2.0 times mean by flow regime
Construction Sanitary tube 1.5 to 4 inch, 316L, sloped up 1/4 inch per foot, no restrictions
Finish / class 3-A, 32 Ra, tri-clamp or welded runs
Valve Three-way leak-protect diversion valve, diverts in under 1 second
Records Safety thermal limit recorder, sensor at tube outlet, chart kept

Hold and Divert Questions

Both are accepted; a sealed positive displacement pump is the simpler system and a magnetic flow meter loop is the more flexible one. The pump needs only its sealed speed, and as rotors and seals wear its delivery falls, so the hold lengthens and the loss shows up as capacity rather than as a safety problem. The meter system uses a centrifugal pump, a control valve and a high-flow divert that trips when flow passes the sealed limit, so it holds the timed flow within a few percent across products of different viscosity, at the cost of three more devices for the inspector to test and seal. On a 100 gpm milk line either works; on a line that alternates milk and cream, the meter loop keeps both products at the same timed flow in the same tube instead of carrying two sealed pump speeds.

In CIP mode the controls cycle the valve between forward and divert so both seats, the divert line and the vented leak-detect cavity all see solution. The mistake is a wash that leaves the valve in forward through the whole caustic step: the divert line and the cavity between the seats get a rinse at best, grow film over a week, and drain back into the balance tank at the next start-up. Write a valve cycle every few minutes into the CIP recipe and check the divert line temperature with a surface probe during the caustic step; if it does not reach the circuit temperature, the solution is not getting there.

The smallest bore that keeps the thickest product turbulent at the sealed flow, which on a milk line usually means 2 to 3 inch. At 100 gpm a 2.5 inch tube runs about 7.3 ft/s and needs about 131 feet; a 3 inch tube at the same flow runs about 5 ft/s and needs about 90 feet, so the larger bore saves 40 feet of sloped tube and supports but drops the Reynolds number by about a sixth. The smaller tube is the safer choice when cream or mix is on the list, because turbulence is what keeps the fastest particle at 1.2 times mean instead of 2.0. Whatever the size, it is fixed from inlet to diversion valve: a reducer, a tee or a thermometer well inside the timed length is a restriction and the inspector will fail it.

Not without a new timing test and a new seal, even if the length is unchanged. Length, diameter, slope, routing and the fittings at either end all go into the timed result, so a tube re-routed around a new tank with the same number of feet still goes back to the inspector for a salt test. The expensive version is a line move where a contractor adds a spool and nobody re-times it; the plant is then pasteurizing without an approved hold until the next inspection finds it. When a tube must change, calculate the new length from the sealed flow, cut it a few percent long, have it timed, and file the test with the sealed setting.

Because at 5 ft/s the milk moves 5 feet for every second a slow sensor spends catching up, and that milk is past the valve before the divert fires. The PMO sets a thermometric response test for the recorder, and the sensor passes it only when it sits bare in the product stream at the tube outlet, within 18 inches of the valve, not in a thick well whose mass lags the product. The same applies to the indicating thermometer beside it. A replaced sensor, a new recorder or a change of transmitter brings back the response test, the cut-in and cut-out check and the valve timing, so budget the inspection visit along with the part and keep a spare sensor of the same type on the shelf.

Related

Milk Pasteurization Heat Exchangers

Applications

Milk Pasteurization

Two legal routes for fluid milk, 161 F for 15 seconds or 145 F for 30 minutes, and the exchanger each needs.

+ Learn More
Pasteurizer Regeneration Sections

Applications

Regeneration Sections

Raw milk heated by pasteurized milk through a plate, 85 to 95 percent, pressure always pointing the safe way.

+ Learn More
Plate vs Tubular HTST Pasteurizers

Applications

Plate vs Tubular HTST

Plates for thin milk and short payback; tubes for viscosity, fiber, fouling and 20-hour runs.

+ Learn More

Quote Request Form:

Questions?

1-805-484-2992

Quotes - Engineering - Sales