Fat, Shortening and Margarine Heat Exchangers

Kept liquid until the crystallizer and never allowed to set on a wall.

Contact us

Solid and semi-solid fats

Everything is about the slip point

Palm stearin, hydrogenated soybean oil, tallow, lard, cocoa butter equivalents and the fat blends that become shortening and margarine are solid or plastic at 70 F and liquid at 110 to 140 F. The exchanger's task is to melt them, hold them, blend them with water and emulsifier where the product is a margarine, and cool the blend toward its crystallization temperature without letting any of it solidify on a tube wall. A wall a few degrees below the slip point grows a layer of fat in minutes that insulates the tube and then breaks off into the product.

This page is about melting and holding fats, the pre-cooler that brings a fat or emulsion to crystallizer feed temperature, and the tempered water that makes both possible.

Melting, holding, pre-cooling and keeping the tube clear

Melting and holding fats

The first exchanger melts the fat or holds it liquid. Holding and transfer heating is a shell-and-tube or tube-in-tube on hot water at 160 to 200 F that keeps the fat 20 to 30 degrees above its slip point. Steam directly on a fat scorches it; hot water at a 20 to 40 degree approach does the job without the flavor.

Every connection, drain, vent and instrument well on a fat line is heat-traced or jacketed, because fat in a dead leg at ambient sets hard. HeatX builds fat exchangers with jacketed return bends, traced drains and no low point that is not heated.

Pre-cooling toward the crystallizer

Shortening and margarine get their texture in a scraped-surface crystallizer that takes the fat or emulsion from about 110 to 130 F down to 50 to 60 F while working the crystals. The crystallizer is expensive per square foot, so the plant pre-cools the blend in a conventional exchanger first. That pre-cooler is where fats set on walls, and it is designed with tempered water on the utility side at 10 to 20 degrees below the slip point of the blend, never tower water at 85 F, staged so the last-pass wall is still above where crystals nucleate.

A margarine emulsion at 80 percent fat and 20 percent aqueous phase is pasteurized at 165 to 175 F on the way to the pre-cooler where the plant requires it, and the emulsion is shear-sensitive: the exchanger runs at 1 to 2 ft/s in a 2 to 3 inch bore so the emulsion does not break in the tubes.

Shell side or tube side, and the shutdown

On a U-tube shell-and-tube the fat goes on the shell side with the tempered water in the tubes, so the fat has the larger flow area and the lower velocity. On a tube-in-tube the fat is in the bore at 2 to 3 inches and the water in the annulus; either way the fat side is arranged to drain completely from a single low point that is heated.

Shutdown is where fat exchangers are lost. Every fat exchanger has a steam-out or hot water connection to the utility side that clears the product side to the drain, and the control sequence runs it automatically when the product pump stops.

90–140°F
slip point across the fat blends
40,000 lb/h
fat flow at the top of the range
10–20 deg
tempered water below slip point on pre-coolers
180°F
hot water melt-out before caustic

The common mistake

Using the plant's tower water loop on the shortening pre-cooler because it was there. The first pass sets a skin of fat on every tube, the pressure drop triples in an hour and the crystallizer starves. Tempered water at 10 to 20 degrees below the slip point costs a small loop and a mixing valve. Send the fat or blend, its slip point, the flow, the temperatures in and out, and whether the product is an emulsion.
Call and talk it through with an engineer: 1-805-484-2992

Fat, shortening and margarine process conditions

Fats are quoted from the melt point outward, so the rows describe the product, the utilities and the build that follow from it. Check them against your line and send your product, flow and temperatures with the request.

Condition Detail
Product Palm stearin, hydrogenated oils, tallow, lard, fat blends, margarine emulsion; slip point 90 to 140 F; 20 to 200 cP liquid
Flow range 2,000 to 40,000 lb/h
Temperatures in / out Melting 70 to 150 F; holding 130 to 160 F; pre-cooling 150 F to 110 to 130 F ahead of the crystallizer
Hold None; emulsions pasteurized at 165 to 175 F for 15 to 30 seconds where required
Utility Hot water at 160 to 200 F on melters; tempered water 10 to 20 degrees below slip point on pre-coolers
Approach 20 to 40 degrees on melting; 10 to 20 degrees on pre-cooling, staged
Construction Single tube-in-tube 2 to 3 inch bore; U-tube shell-and-tube with fat on the shell side; steam-traced connections
Finish / class 304L or 316L, 32 Ra; food-grade drainable; heated drains and vents
CIP Hot water melt-out at 180 F before caustic; caustic at 170 F on emulsion lines; steam-out

Slip Point Questions

As a closed loop with its own pump, a trim exchanger on tower or chilled water, and a three-way mixing valve holding the supply setpoint. For a blend with a 110 F slip point the loop runs at 90 to 100 F, 10 to 20 degrees below it. The loop is pumped at high flow so the water rises only 5 to 10 degrees through the pre-cooler and the coldest wall stays near the supply temperature. Size the trim exchanger on the full pre-cooling duty, because every Btu the fat gives up still has to leave the loop.

Because the 20 percent water phase is where microbes grow and where salt attacks stainless; the fat phase does neither. A straight shortening line is an oil duty: 304L, drained hot, opened on interval. A margarine emulsion with milk solids, salt at 1 to 2 percent and flavor in the water carries dairy-style spoilage risk, so it is pasteurized at 165 to 175 F and the emulsion side is built fully drainable to a sanitary standard with gasket joints that open. The salt, at a chloride level that pits 304 over a season, is the reason the emulsion contact surface is 316L. Tell us whether the line will ever run emulsion, because a fat-only build cannot be upgraded later.

Three setpoints move together: tempered water, holding temperature and melt-out temperature. Going from a soft blend with a 95 F slip point to palm stearin at 130 F, a pre-cooler still running 85 F water is 45 degrees below the new slip point and sets a skin of fat on every tube in the first pass. The reverse is safer but wastes crystallizer capacity. Plants with several products keep a setpoint table per recipe in the controls, flush with the incoming fat untill the outlet temperature reads in range, and only then open the valve to the crystallizer. A pre-cooler sized at the small approach for the hardest fat will handle the softest; a pre-cooler sized for the softest will not handle the hardest, so quote the line on the highest slip point it will ever run.

Indirectly, through how steadily it delivers the blend to the crystallizer. The crystallizer sets texture by how fast it takes the fat from about 110 to 130 F down to 50 to 60 F under shear, and its program assumes a fixed inlet. If the pre-cooler outlet swings 10 degrees as flow changes, the crystallizer sees a changing load, the crystal form and the firmness drift lot to lot, and the line blames the crystallizer. A pre-cooler with a modulating tempered water valve on its outlet, holding a band of 2 to 3 degrees, does more for texture than any amount of extra area.

Melt and flush the fat out with 180 F water first; chemical should only meet a wall that is already bare metal. Caustic sent into a unit still coated with fat saponifies the layer instead of cleaning the wall, foams in the CIP return and arrives too weak to finish the job. Run the hot water melt-out until the drain runs clear, then caustic at 170 F on emulsion lines and a hot rinse. Never put steam directly on a fat-coated product side: it scorches the layer onto the wall.

Related

Vegetable Oil Heating and Cooling Heat Exchangers

Applications

Vegetable Oil Heating & Cooling

The heaters and coolers around the refinery: degumming, neutralizing, bleaching feed and storage.

+ Learn More
Deodorizer Heat Recovery Exchangers

Applications

Deodorizer Heat Recovery

Recover 60 to 80 percent of the deodorizer heat oil-to-oil, then close the last degrees on thermal fluid.

+ Learn More
Bleaching and Winterization Heat Exchangers

Applications

Bleaching & Winterization

The heater in front of the bleacher and the chiller in front of the wax filter, at opposite ends of the range.

+ Learn More

Quote Request Form:

Questions?

1-805-484-2992

Quotes - Engineering - Sales